every smith
  • MS: Max Smith's blog
  • History to the Defeated
  • every smith: independent creative consultants
  • Words: Max - a brief bio
  • Sites to see

Leamington Letters #115: The true triumph of Reason

16/8/2016

7 Comments

 
Picture
An early Corbynista?
The English voice from the adjacent table was unmistakable as it soared over the terrace of TEN, the new and fashionable fusion restaurant in Uzès*. “And, of course” said the voice, “I’ve now missed the deadline for paying the £25 each to buy the right for my daughters a vote in the election. It’s disgraceful.”
 
I admit that this eavesdropping, which referred to the Court of Appeal judgement, has overtones of overheard-in-Waitrose about it, but even in this – usually idyllic - part of the world, there is no escaping the machinations of the proponents of the attempted coup. After a 10 day sojourn in the UK, which coincided with our Constituency Labour Party nomination meeting (93 – 25 in favour of Corbyn since you ask) and included a dozen or more impromptu and pessimistic discussions about the future of the country and the party, I had expected to return to a few day’s grace and welcome respite from the day-to-day debate.
 
But it was not to be. As the British Left move south, they bring with them their concerns and commitments. And they find a ready audience here in Uzès where the ex-pat community tends to eschew the stereotypical Englishman abroad and embrace a more cosmopolitan worldview. Equally, the Uzètiens, not solely through self-interest, are as anxious about the impact of Brexit and the turmoil in le parti travailliste as are we all.
 
In fact, the French struggle to understand much of what is going on. Trotskyism in France, for example, is not a gratuitous term of abuse but a description of a particular and legitimate ideology which was forged in opposition to Stalinism. And where does Trotsky advocate “entryism”? (He doesn’t anywhere, as a French friend pointed out forcibly to me the other day. Exactement!)
 
But the requirement for precision and accuracy – dare we call it truth? – in political discourse is pretty much de rigeur in France. And you don’t need me to point out that this is very different from the standards of our British politicians and journalists, where a recent academic study has found that precisely 0% of Corbyn’s speeches have been accurately and comprehensively reported in ‘newspapers’ such as The Mail and The Express and barely at all at the BBC and The Guardian.
 
I suspect that the French tradition is the result of its respect for les philosophes and a well-established tradition of rigorous and challenging intellectual contribution to political thought. In Britain, this is despised; in France, it is welcomed, embraced. In Britain, we dismiss people as “too clever by half” or “Two-Brains”; in France, we read them, listen to them, learn from them.
 
It is this tradition which prompts the support which Corbyn commands amongst our French friends and the shock and amazement provoked by the abuse heaped upon him by his opponents inside the party: on the one hand, a man whose contributions are reasoned, thoughtful, and quietly spoken; on the other, snide sound-bites, shouted.
 
But, as Voltaire famously put it, “The true triumph of reason is that it enables us to get along with those who do not possess it.”
 
Let’s hope so.

* I commend this place to you, particularly as they bring down from Brittany, really good, cool water oysters and the multi-national staff are exceptional.

Today from the everysmith vaults: The Cowboy Junkies and a live show at the Newport Folk Festival in August 2008. Plus a rendition of Dirty Water, part of my own small and solo celebration of the Sox winning the make-up game in Cleveland last night, which I didn't see live because of a dinner date.
7 Comments
MartinH
16/8/2016 13:30:38

Agree with most of this. Not sure your Romanticized view of the French is 100% accurate, but it is true that they pay more attention to intellect and thinking than do we.

Reply
Chris
16/8/2016 13:31:28

Another long hiatus but broken with a good post. Thanks.

Reply
Allan
16/8/2016 15:29:38

Yes, the origins are the epithet Trot seem to have nothing to do with Trotsky and everything to do with renegade Communists. But as you say, who cares about what it means. As far as the Mail is concerned, a word means exactly what it wants it to mean. Nothing more or less.

Reply
BenD
17/8/2016 10:37:39

The thing about those epithets - Iain McLeod and Willets? - is that they weren't even accurate. And didn't Wilson say that the problem with his first Labour cabinet was that it included too many 1st class Oxford degrees?

Reply
Allan
17/8/2016 10:44:25

He did and he was wrong. The problem with that first couple of years of Labour government was the right wing, the likes of Woodrow Wyatt, undermining the government. That and the inheritance of "thirteen years of Conservative misrule"!

Reply
Jack
17/8/2016 10:55:10

You might also add that even the word 'ideology' is a problem in UK politics. George Monbiot in The Grauniad talks also about how neoliberalism dropped out of use as a term just as the policies of neoliberalism became more coherent and more damaging. The term was not used, but the policies from Chile onwards became even more vicious and universal. One of the achievements of McDonnell is that we can now use it accurately and usefully to describe the issue. Unless, of course, it is banned by the NEC!

Reply
Simon
17/8/2016 11:21:13

The Monbiot piece is a good one, and we should respect the Guardian for publishing it, given their current neoliberal bias. Your broader point about the way in which politics are presented and discussed is right on. But glad to see that Uzes is pro-Corbyn.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Max Smith

    European writer, radical, restaurateur and Red Sox fan. 70-something husband, father, step-father, grandfather and son. Resident in Warwick, England.

    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Baseball
    Books
    Film
    Food + Drink
    French Letters
    Leamington Letters
    Media
    Music
    People
    Personal
    Politics
    Sport