every smith
  • MS: Max Smith's blog
  • History to the Defeated
  • every smith: independent creative consultants
  • Words: Max - a brief bio
  • Sites to see

Leamington Letters #70: Gone, but not forgotten

17/2/2014

11 Comments

 
We chose to follow the advice of Elizabeth David: an omelette and a glass of wine. I was in the French bistro Angelus, with Rick Gekoski, having an all-too-infrequent and, on this occasion, all-too-brief lunch. We were talking books, because Rick is a Booker Prize judge, rare-book dealer and writer, and I would like to be any or all of those.

At some point, Rick mentioned that he had enjoyed a particular blog of mine, which concerned a restaurant which we had both frequented many years ago. And digging it up from the archives on the train home, I noted that I had announced my plan to blog about Rick's last book, Lost, Stolen or Shredded, as soon as I had given it due consideration. By which I meant as soon as I had read it again, because one reads Rick firstly for entertainment and secondly for education and elucidation. Or I do.
Picture
I realised that I have never honoured that promise. So I will do so now, because it is almost a year since publication and Rick is already well-advanced on his next book. And because I realised this weekend that a couple of works were missing from my shelves. And yes, I did read the book a second time.

The sub-title of Lost, Stolen or Shredded is Stories of Missing Works of Art and Literature. This is not, I suspect, merely to attract the attention of internet search engines, but because each chapter is, in fact, a great story told by a great story-teller, with a wonderful turn of phrase.

Consider the opening sentences of the foreword: “He collected absences. For him they were more intense, vibrant and real than the presences that they shadowed.” I remember reading this to Jill on the train back from the launch party, and remarking that it was worthy of the subject, who is, of course, Franz Kafka, and the  story concerns his visit to the Louvre to gaze not upon the Mona Lisa, but at the space that the painting had occupied before being stolen.

“He collected absences.” There is no way one is not going to read on after that. And so one does, learning about the stolen Mona Lisa, the destroyed Churchill portrait by Sutherland, the burned manuscripts of Byron and Larkin's diaries and Joyce's juvenilia, Et Tu, Healey, and the bejewelled copy of the Rubaiyat which went down on the Titanic. All are written as he talks - with eloquence and fluency and wry humour. 

I doubt whether the transformation from Radio 4 talks to book required too much editing. In both forms, he tells stories, each of which addresses the general (the art or literature and its place in the world) and the particular (Rick's individual relationship with it).

Absence, caused by loss, theft, shredding or sinking, is the theme. Does the absence of a poem, a diary, a painting leave the world a worse place? Rick mentions his inability to look at the work of Eric Gill without "a shudder of remembrance" of Gill's activities with children. I share that revulsion. I also care little about the destruction of Larkin's diaries, for example, and think that everything else the man wrote is diminished by the fact that those diaries were once written and did exist, that they were part of the 'complete works' of Larkin and that one's response to a Larkin poem now is informed by the knowledge of those diaries and their contents.

Today of course those diaries could probably have been erased not by the ceremony of ritual burning, but by the simple click of the delete button. And Rick's current preoccupations include the life and death of the book itself. Like me, he reads primarily on the Kindle, buying the real thing only for writers and volumes of particular importance. (I bought an actual copy of the reissue of Keywords by Raymond Williams this morning, the first such purchase for some months, probably since Lost, Stolen or Shredded, come to think of it.)

But for Rick, as a publisher of beautiful books and a dealer in rare ones, the convenience of the Kindle medium must be also a source of regret. We do not own an iBook or a Kindle book; we merely have the right to read it. (Nor do we own an iTune: Bruce Willis is currently engaged in a law suit to enable him to leave his iTunes music to his children.)

This is what we have lost, or had stolen from us. Our sense of direct, proprietary involvement with our books and our music. Our ownership, on a personal level, with both the artefact and the intellectual content.

I know this is not on the same scale as the loss of the library in the Villa of the Papyri in Herculaneum, another of Rick's stories.

But is for me. As well as my missing first edition of Keywords, inscribed to me by Raymond Williams, I discovered yesterday that my cassettes of Dylan and the Dead rehearsing in San Rafael in 1987 are also gone, baby, gone.

To paraphrase Stalin, which I do seldom, the loss of thousands of scrolls in Herculaneum is a statistic. The loss of that book, and those tapes, is a tragedy.

Today from the everysmith vaults: Miles Davis, opening for the Dead at Fillmore West in April 1970. Here's Phil Lesh in his autobiography, Searching for the Sound, “As I listened, leaning over the amps with my jaw hanging agape, trying to comprehend the forces that Miles was unleashing on stage, I was thinking, 'What's the use. How can we possibly play after this? We should just go home and try to digest this unbelievable shit.”

11 Comments
MarkD
17/2/2014 02:28:12

Didn't read the book but heard some of the 'stories' on the radio. Understand your sense of personal loss, which is the more profound because it is personal. You can still stream those tapes at archive.org. PS just realised the last time I commented was when you promised this review! Better late etc etc!

Reply
Allan
17/2/2014 02:33:15

I wonder. Is the world diminished by the absence of bejewelled copies of the Rubaiyat or Larkin's pathetic fantasies? Not really. It would be if Keywords had never been written, but your loss is easily remedied as you have done. It's the content not the artefact. But thanks - will read Gekoski's book now.

Reply
Ellen
17/2/2014 02:38:26

Just realised I can't find my copy of Elizabeth David's "An Omelette and a Glass of Wine"!

Reply
Thom
17/2/2014 03:09:46

There are some serious points here. What I liked about the book was Gekoski's individual relationships with each of the works of art or literature. (it's what I enjoy about your blogs, too.) His bibliomemoir Outside of a Dog takes this conceit to extremes and is all the better for it, because it reflects a personal not merely a professional interest in books and paintings. It is interesting that you have introduced music into this, which he doesn't. Why? There are many works which we know existed but have no record of.

Reply
Matt
17/2/2014 04:24:42

If we don't have a record of them, you might be able to get a CD!

Reply
Jack
18/2/2014 03:56:23

Actually this is a good point. Where are the stories of missing music? Not as interesting or not of interest to RG?

MichaelB
17/2/2014 03:30:00

Your loss ... our gain. Thanks for these musings.

Reply
CJ
17/2/2014 15:27:04

That Miles Quintet set. Chick Corea on electric piano. Interesting to read Phil Lesh but even more to read what Miles said about it. Look it up. He came to love the hippies after these shows. They got it. The jazz guys didn't.

Reply
Ben
19/2/2014 09:27:52

So are you the Max Smith in Staying Up? Guessed you were. No Sky Bles blogs for about three years ...

Reply
Max
25/2/2014 02:01:58

'fraid so. Much of what he wrote isn't true, of course, but it is accurate! The City situation is desperate and I just don't know what to think. They are playing games with our club and my response is ... A plague on both of your houses.

Reply
Max
25/2/2014 02:05:14

Re the music or lack of it in the book. I do know that there was some correspondence between Rick and Kazuo Ishiguro concerning the "missing" Dylan song I'm Not There. But then of course it surfaced on the complete Basement Tapes!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Max Smith

    European writer, radical, restaurateur and Red Sox fan. 70-something husband, father, step-father, grandfather and son. Resident in Warwick, England.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Baseball
    Books
    Film
    Food + Drink
    French Letters
    Leamington Letters
    Media
    Music
    People
    Personal
    Politics
    Sport