every smith
  • MS: Max Smith's blog
  • History to the Defeated
  • every smith: independent creative consultants
  • Words: Max - a brief bio
  • Sites to see

Leamington Letters #79: Adventures in the land of Bob

9/5/2014

13 Comments

 
Picture

Most of my friends and – especially – my family regard me as a Dylan obsessive. I have every album in almost every re-mastered manifestation. I have thousands of  shows. I have complete sets of The Telegraph and The Bridge and Isis. I have signed firsts of Tarantula and Chronicles, the latter in both US and UK editions. I have shelves full of biographies and analysis. I have on my office walls signed photographs and original flybills dating back to 1961. I have attended concerts pretty much every year since 1965. Each morning I check the set lists from his last gig even before the Red Sox box score. And barely a day goes by without listening to the man, quoting him, discussing him, thinking about him.

But I’m an amateur.

In David Kinney’s new book, The Dylanologists: Adventures in the Land of Bob, I don’t figure at all. Because, compared with his subjects, I’m normal.

Kinney is a Pullitzer Prize winning journalist and his research is extensive and meticulous. It tells the stories not only the (in)famous AJ Weberman, the man who hunted through Dylan’s garbage, Mitch Blank, the “hypnotist collector” and Bill Pagel who owns Bob’s high chair, prom ticket, high school year books and even the house in Duluth where he lived his first years; but also of scores of apparently ordinary folk who have quietly devoted their lives to a study of Bob; more, who have lived their lives through Bob.

In Kinney’s words, they fell down “the rabbit hole”. And the further they went, the further they had to go. To visit Hibbing, to see every show, endlessly to analyse lyrics and performances.

The book’s epigraph has the following exchange:

Fan: “You don’t know who I am, but I know who you are.”

Bob Dylan: “Let’s keep it that way.”

Kinney doesn't. His book is, in many ways, as revealing of Bob as it is of his fans. Bob is a fan: of Woody Guthrie, Of Elvis, of John Lennon. So we learn about the hike across country to visit the dying Guthrie in hospital, of his kissing the floor of the studio where Presley recorded, of searching out Lennon’s house and Strawberry Fields in Liverpool. And one need not be an obsessive listener to recognise and appreciate the vastness of his listening and reading and the ways in which he incorporated it all into his songs and his art.

The Dylanologists is, however, primarily about Bob’s fans rather than Bob himself. Its subjects include those who lead disappointed lives because they are saddened by Bob’s failure to live up to their expectations and those who, like me, are content to follow where he leads, falling on each new album, each show, with renewed enthusiasm.

Bob is 73 this month. I am 65 in a couple of months. I cannot imagine my life without his. But I am not, in Kinney’s sense, a Dylanologist.

I am just a fan, who enjoys his adventures in the land of Bob, but occasionally visits other lands as well. We need the balance.

Today from the everysmith vaults: I have been listening to an extraordinary series of shows in Japan, in which Bob has found his voice. The singing is powerful and rich and full of nuance. How does he do it?!

13 Comments
CJ
9/5/2014 04:27:46

Haha! Bet you checked the index! You are right about the voice in the recent shows. And, interestingly, the band is almost anonymous - a backing band. It's a conscious move. What does it mean?

Reply
CJ
11/5/2014 02:19:47

Update. Things have changed again. Last few shows very different in style. Bob growling again!

Reply
JamieD
9/5/2014 04:39:50

Of course, Bob is not the only one to attract such a following. You may possibly be familiar with a band called the Grateful Dead, which also gave birth to thousands of completist obsessives!

Reply
Allan
9/5/2014 04:46:21

There is also the parallel with sports teams. It is clear that some people are predisposed to this kind of idolatory and the only question is who or what will be the object of their desires. Often the result of some random epiphanic moment.

Reply
Ellie
9/5/2014 09:27:46

They are all men! what is it about you guys and completism?

Reply
Jack
9/5/2014 09:41:49

Bob said it: "let's keep it that way". the beauty of Dylan's music and lyrics is that they are ours - we can take them any way we wish. The Dylanologists give us a steer sometimes. But the important response is our own.

Reply
Tony
9/5/2014 10:11:25

I understand all this. I get Bob. But I have never understood nor got the obsession. He had his moment: sometime in the late 60s and 70s. He - and you - are living on those great albums: Freewheelin' up to Blood on the Tracks.After that? Sort of ok.

Reply
Anders
12/5/2014 05:06:15

This isn't quite true but it's close enough. The thing about Dylan is that he is emblematic. One needs to keep listening in the same way as one needs to keep checking the news. Not much may have happened but you never know ...

Reply
Tony
12/5/2014 05:30:56

... and no news is good news I suppose!

Martin
20/5/2014 07:49:50

and you could leave out what happened between 'Blonde on Blonde' and 'Blood on the Tracks'

Reply
Max
17/5/2014 03:24:20

Leaving Jerry Garcia's funeral, Bob said to John Scher, "That man back there is the only one who knew what it's like to be me."

Reply
martin
20/5/2014 07:58:44

But could Gerry have said the same about Bob? I don't think so.

Reply
English Washington link
2/4/2021 02:05:31

Thanks foor writing this

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Max Smith

    European writer, radical, restaurateur and Red Sox fan. 70-something husband, father, step-father, grandfather and son. Resident in Warwick, England.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Baseball
    Books
    Film
    Food + Drink
    French Letters
    Leamington Letters
    Media
    Music
    People
    Personal
    Politics
    Sport