every smith
  • MS: Max Smith's blog
  • History to the Defeated
  • every smith: independent creative consultants
  • Words: Max - a brief bio
  • Sites to see

Not Dark Yet #372: Why the hell did we vote Labour?

22/8/2024

8 Comments

 
Picture
Me with Emily Thornberry's tour bus in the days when I still had illusions.
Did you watch the feed from the Democratic National Convention  the other night? Did you watch the Obamas and marvel at the rhetoric, the fluency, the passion, the intellect? And did you conclude, reluctantly, that there is no equivalent in the UK; that the apparatchiks of this new manifestation of New Labour have no desire to enthuse or inspire the electorate with ideas and policies?

More than fifty years ago, when I was already a seasoned campaigner and voter for Labour, a favourite (and effective) canvassing line was “Vote Labour with no illusions”. This thought has kept me going through every election since 1970. With no illusions, I have voted for Labour under the leadership of Harold Wilson, James Callaghan, Michael Foot, Neil Kinnock, Tony Blair, Gordon Brown, Ed Miliband, Jeremy Cornyn and Keir Starmer.

Why do we do this time after time, with and without illusions?

Because a Labour Government will reverse the child benefit cap.

Because a Labour Government will protect pensioners’ winter fuel allowance.

Because a Labour Government will never suspend MPs for voting according to their conscience.

Because a labour Government will never expel the likes of Faiza Shaheen just because they can.

Because a Labour Government will never select the likes of Luke Lakehurst to represent the party.

Because a Labour Government will protect the green belt against development.

Because a Labour Government will stop sending arms to countries occupying other countries.

Because a Labour Government will make refugees welcome and create safe and legal routes.

Because a Labour Government will never appoint disgraced dinosaurs  such as Milburn and Smith to government.

Because a Labour Government will renationalise the water companies.

I could go on and probably will on another occasion. Meantime, I am beginning to recognise that after these five decades, I misunderstood the advice.

I was voting Labour with delusions.
​
Today from the everysmith vaults: Playing right now (rain has stopped play in Manchester) is The Grateful Dead on the 24 August 1972 at Berkeley. A brilliant and generous recording (the Monday and Tuesday shows also) from John Hilgart. Thanks.
8 Comments
Emma R
22/8/2024 16:05:14

There was of course a Labour leader who was charismatic, thoughtful, and popular. Jeremy something? I often wonder what happened to him. He had my vote.

Reply
PaulV
22/8/2024 16:20:19

Because a Labour Government would never allow someone like Wes Streeting to introduce private finance to the NHS.

Reply
Leo
22/8/2024 16:22:49

… would not allow someone like Wes Streeting full stop.

Reply
Allan
23/8/2024 10:19:13

Have you observed the arrogance of the Streetings and Ashworths of this world. They really are deeply unpleasant people and they are now, like the school bully who becomes head boy, they are relishing their opportunity to dismiss all other people and all other shades of option.

Reply
Max
23/8/2024 10:34:57

Yes, very true. I heard that one of the problems for them in the campaign was that they were disliked by their membership who didn't turn out to work for them. A lesson for many others. A decent candidate in North Durham could easily send Akehurst packing.

Reply
Allan
24/8/2024 10:33:54

PS You forgot collusion.

Reply
Alex
24/8/2024 09:54:42

Had forgotten that Corbyn's team also centered on the need for change. But their's was a statement with which one could agree or not. Starmer's was an order. an authoritarian You will obey.

Reply
Ellie
2/9/2024 09:57:05

You look younger … but wiser!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

     Max Smith

    European writer, radical, restaurateur and Red Sox fan. 70-something husband, father, step-father. and grandfather. Resident in Warwick, England.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Baseball
    Books
    Film
    Food + Drink
    French Letters
    Leamington Letters
    Media
    Music
    People
    Personal
    Politics
    Sport