every smith
  • MS: Max Smith's blog
  • History to the Defeated
  • every smith: independent creative consultants
  • Words: Max - a brief bio
  • Sites to see

Leamington Letters #136: A Magyar masterpiece

1/12/2017

8 Comments

 
Picture
I have never had much time for the honours system in the UK, apart - obviously - from the medals awarded to my dad. But another exception must be the MBE conferred on Richard Phillips who, with his wife Veronica, is the driving force behind Leamington Music in general and the International String Quartet Series in particular.
 
Over the years, the couple have brought to Leamington and Warwick some of the great quartets, many of them (the Atrium, the Petersen) appearing long before they achieved national and international critical acclaim.
 
Last night, we saw the return to Leamington of the Kodály Quartet from Hungary. The Kodály are emphatically not up and coming – they celebrated fifty years of playing together in 2016 – but despite this, and despite their mittel-European tradition, they always surprise and delight.
 
They began with Haydn, proving that they can play this kind of thing standing on their heads. There is a pattern emerging throughout the chamber music world of giving us a example of Haydn’s extraordinarily prolific output. Like the Dead opening with Bertha or Bob with Crash on the Levee, Haydn serves as a warm-up for many quartets, a plate of nibbles before the main course.
 
And so it was last night. But the Kodály’s main course was remarkable. I had never heard of Erno Dohnanyi before I saw the programme and this is very much my loss. His String Quartet #2, composed in 1906, was a revelation – by turns haunting and menacing, passionate and angry, evil and innocent, intense and sensitive.
 
The violinists Attila and Ferenc, the latter looking like a young Lewis Litt for you fans of Suits, swapped roles for this piece. But for me the highlights were the drive of the cello in the second movement and, in the finale, the opportunity for the viola to take centre stage. From my seat, directly behind the viola player, János appeared as if a Soviet-era discus thrower, all massively broad shoulders and close-cropped hair. But the sound he produced was beautiful.
 
Richard’s programme notes quote a claim that this is “one of the greatest, if not the greatest, post-Brahms Romantic quartet”. I don’t know enough to make that kind of judgement but I do know that, not least in its emotional range, it is close to a masterpiece. And I also know that, in their performance last evening, the collective virtuosity of the Kodály did it justice.
 
I am grateful I was there. Grateful to the quartet for their performance. And grateful to Richard and Veronica who make this kind of experience possible time after time.
 
Today from the everysmith vaults: I have no Dohnanyi in the vaults (yet), but I do have the Kodály playing string quartets by Kodály. So that’s what I’m listening to as I type.
8 Comments
DanS
1/12/2017 12:32:55

A new name to me too. Will check him out. And know what you mean about Haydn - but there are worse things!

Reply
Chris
1/12/2017 13:02:49

Don’t share your enthusiasm for chamber music. My concert going is for big set piece compositions - symphonies, choral stuff that you can’t reproduce at home via CD. But each to his or her own.

Reply
Ellie
1/12/2017 19:49:20

Good piece. Just a little negativity (Haydn) but unusually upbeat and positive. And lovely tribute to R and V Phillips.

Reply
Sue
2/12/2017 08:08:10

What about the Schumann?

Reply
Max
2/12/2017 11:40:39

Not my favourite piece by not my favourite composer. It was fine. Nothing to criticise, nothing to rave about. But should add that an absolute delight was the encore - Shostakovich Polka. Witty and exuberant.

Reply
Martin
6/12/2017 12:33:55

Hear! Hear! to the Phillipses and their contribution to the music, and to those like you and Neil who have sponsored performances in the past. But how unfair to Haydn. We have to have the balance and stillness of the classical before all that churning romanticism. Never the ice-cream and jelly before the soup and sea-food. I expect music students write essays on concert programmes recapitulating the history of western 'classical' music. I think it is discussed in Robert Persig's book about motorcycles.

Reply
Allan
6/12/2017 16:04:17

Max, I'm closer to Martin's view than yours and a little suspicious of your implicit characterisation of Haydn as lightweight. If you listened more carefully, I suspect that you would hear some quite profound music and Martin is right that the 'stillness' of the Haydn is a necessary pre-requisite for a concentrated listen to the 'churning romanticism'. But will check out the Dohnanyi.

Reply
Max
6/12/2017 16:33:01

Hmmm. Not going to argue genres with either of you, but for the record, Dohnanyi Quartet #2 not romanticism if any kind, and certainly not churning!




Leave a Reply.

    Picture

     Max Smith

    European writer, radical, restaurateur and Red Sox fan. 70-something husband, father, step-father. and grandfather. Resident in Warwick, England.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Baseball
    Books
    Film
    Food + Drink
    French Letters
    Leamington Letters
    Media
    Music
    People
    Personal
    Politics
    Sport