every smith
  • MS: Max Smith's blog
  • History to the Defeated
  • every smith: independent creative consultants
  • Words: Max - a brief bio
  • Sites to see

Less is more: why we don't want vineyard expansion

6/1/2012

8 Comments

 
Picture
Illustration: Lara Voce

I remember an article in Punch, probably forty years ago now, in which the late Alan Coren imagined a London which had been taken over by estate agents. Anything south of the river was re-classified as ‘Surrey’; anything north, ‘Hampstead’.

We’re going to get something like this if the new EU proposal to liberalise vineyard planting rights goes through: west will be a huge Bordeaux appellation, east a smaller but no less dominant Burgundy, with a patch of Champagne and a strip of Rhone. In theory, by the end of 2016, Bordeaux could increase from 120,000 ha to 220,000; Burgundy could double from 28,000 ha to 59,000.  The Iberian peninsula will basically become Rioja on the east and Douro on the west, because the vineyard areas of Rioja in Spain and Douro in Portugal could increase in size by factors of six and five respectively.

The objective, apparently, is “to boost the wine sector’s competitiveness by reducing production costs”, which is free-market bollocks-speak for making cheaper wine to sell in the supermarkets.

Let’s for the moment put aside the experience of Australia and New Zealand, where unrestricted planting has produced massive over-supply, falling prices and bankruptcies, and concentrate on Europe.

Even without this new proposal, we still produce 175m hl of wine each year and consume only 130m hl. In other words, supply is once again exceeding demand by a comfortable margin.

It’s a wine lake. And the last time there was a wine lake of this magnitude, the EU introduced a planting ban, as a result of which we achieved some kind of balance between supply and demand.

We managed to create a market in which the good producers could flourish, an environment in which good wine could stand out rather than be drowned in a tsunami of mediocrity. That policy will be reversed if the current proposals are implemented.

Not Dark Yet does not react in Daily Mail knee-jerk fashion to every idea that comes out of Brussels. I actually approve of many. But this is insane.

It's insane because there is already too much wine being produced. It's insane because too much of it is the lowest common denominator stuff which this proposal will encourage. It's insane because the whole concept of terroir will be undermined. It's insane because historic names and great sites will be tarnished.

We are still, just about, members of the European Union. Thirteen countries have already registered their opposition to these “catastrophic” plans. If Britain joined them, there would be a majority against.

Wouldn’t it be great to be part of the majority in Europe? And in such a good cause?

Today's listening: The Coull Quartet, our local band, playing Haydn. Exquisite.

8 Comments
Jill
7/1/2012 02:07:53

Loving the new illustrated blog!

Reply
Sean
15/1/2012 12:33:50

Agree whole-heartedly.

Reply
Sean
15/1/2012 12:34:22

With both. Your blog, and Jill's comment :)

Reply
Max Smith link
15/1/2012 14:04:19

Thanks Sean. Much appreciated. Please keep the comments coming.

Reply
Richard Pearce
15/1/2012 16:36:59

I agree as well - but it must be the late Alan Coren rather than Giles i think.

Reply
Max Smith link
15/1/2012 23:38:52

Thank you Richard. Can't believe I wrote Giles instead of Alan. Have made the change but your comment will remain as a salutary lesson to me.

Reply
myers
19/1/2012 04:32:55

I'm looking forward to Black Tower,Blue Nun and Mateus Rose being the only choices in 2015!

Reply
myers
19/1/2012 04:40:22

On a serious note, my Clos du Cubbington has an excellent new vintage; called "Beaujolais New Spew."

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

     Max Smith

    European writer, radical, restaurateur and Red Sox fan. 70-something husband, father, step-father. and grandfather. Resident in Warwick, England.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Baseball
    Books
    Film
    Food + Drink
    French Letters
    Leamington Letters
    Media
    Music
    People
    Personal
    Politics
    Sport