every smith
  • MS: Max Smith's blog
  • History to the Defeated
  • every smith: independent creative consultants
  • Words: Max - a brief bio
  • Sites to see

Lettres d'Uzès #59: Pirates, Punks & Politics

6/9/2015

11 Comments

 
Picture
Don't know whom to credit for this pic. Apologies if I have infringed anyone's copyright.
I can’t remember precisely when my love affair with football started to wane. It must have been sometime after the 1997-1998 season, because I remember the events of that campaign vividly, even without being reminded by Rick Gekoski’s excellent Staying Up: A Fan behind the Scenes in the Premiership. I remember particularly our win at the Villa on the 14th February in the FA Cup, the goal scored by Moldovan, and that dreadful penalty shoot-out at Sheffield United which ended our hopes of another 1987 Cup triumph.

So I’m guessing that I stopped going to every game sometime in the early 00s, and my attendance since has been limited to special games and those to which I was invited to share rare roast beef and red wine in the Directors’ Box. I think this is partly because Guy went off to university and Rick Gekoski himself to London, but it is also because of a growing disenchantment with the way football was going: cheats on the park and crooks in the boardroom, as someone – maybe me - has said.

But I still get it. I still get the extraordinary euphoria that football can generate. And I still get the sense of identification of a fan with a club.

Hell, as readers of Staying Up will know, I was part of it. Rick reports my lachrymosity on one occasion and my anger and depression on many, so it must be true. Or at least accurate. And his book records the travails of fans who live for results over which they have no control. It produces the highest of highs and the lowest of lows.

Staying Up is one of the few books which chronicle this from the inside. Nick Hornby’s Fever Pitch is more personal but has the same resonance for fans of any team. A Season with Verona by Tim Parks has a slightly different agenda, using his away trips to develop a theory of national character. And The Miracle of Castel di Sangro by Joe McGinness is about passion and corruption and, incidentally, about the growing involvement of the author in the affairs of the club: from objective reporter to passionate and ultimately disenchanted supporter.

Now, there is a new (or newish) book which addresses these issues. It is by Nick Davidson and it is entitled Pirates, Punks & Politics: Falling in Love with a Radical Football Club. It is a football book but it is primarily a political book, about a club which is a creation and reflection of a left-wing, anti-racist, anti-sexist, anti-fascist and anti-homophobic community from the wrong side of the Hamburg tracks.

Nick Davidson was a Watford fan who, before finding true love with FC St Pauli, looked to non-league football (in the same way as I – somewhat desultorily – tried out Leamington) but found the same kind of squabbles and pettiness in the lower levels as he had identified at the top of the game.  In St Pauli, he found a warm welcome from a club and, more importantly, fans (pirates, punks and street politicians) who shared his purist and non-commercial hopes for the beautiful game.

I am late to this bandwagon and, to date, my interest and involvement is limited to checking St Pauli’s result every weekend and watching Youtube footage of the antics of the club’s extraordinary fan base. But one day, I will get to Millerntor.

And I will get there before it’s too late, before St Pauli goes the way of almost every club; its values lost as it finds that the game is merely another cog in the machine.

As all political lives end in failure,  so all fans’ lives end in disillusion. But in the meantime, I commend to you all the volumes mentioned above, especially Nick Davidson and Rick Gekoski. While you are reading them, you will be reminded – however briefly – why the beautiful game is, well, beautiful.

Today from the everysmith vaults: Still with Yo La Tengo. This isn’t Mozart – it needs time to appreciate fully.

11 Comments
Allan
6/9/2015 14:52:01

Yes, FC St Pauli has become a bandwagon and that is changing the nature of club and fan base. Like tourists complaining that the little fishing village is now just a holiday resort. Be careful when you make your pilgrimage. You will contribute to the destruction of what you most admire.

Reply
Mark
6/9/2015 16:51:35

Wouldn't have thought to link those four books, each of which is a classic of its kind. You're right though - none of them are simply about football. They are about fans. Which is what football is about.

Reply
Doug
7/9/2015 08:30:55

Of the (five actually Mark!) books you mention, The Miracle is the most rewarding and the one that probably makes your point most strongly. As you say, the transformation of McGinness from reporter to passionate fan to disillusioned cynic is a great read. Good blog - thanks.

Reply
JohnP
7/9/2015 09:40:29

Did you know Nick Davidson was a Warwick Uni alumnus?

Reply
JohnP
7/9/2015 09:51:59

... and he has written a couple of other books which you should read: Modern Football is Rubbish and Modern Football is Still Rubbish. The disenchantment you reference is widespread and Davidson nails it.

Reply
Sean
7/9/2015 10:52:37

Football died years back. The list is long as to reasons why. Currently Liverpool fans on the Kop are having to apply for accreditation to be official flag bearers to the club. Says it all. When I went to Wembley last year I was greeted with a corporate whore on a loud speaker welcoming me to 'this clash between then lions of Aston Villa and the reds of Liverpool. Let's hear some noise for both teams!' I nearly turned and walked out.

Reply
Thom
8/9/2015 07:07:13

The problem with Davidson's book is that he has adopted the club because of its roots in a community, and he is not part of that community. He is as much a tourist as those he mentions who use it as a stag night destination, and as much as you will be when you travel to Hamburg.

Reply
CJ
8/9/2015 09:58:08

Not Mozart? Needs time? Depends on what level you listen to Mozart. Think maybe you should delve a little deeper! (Not to diss Yo La Tengo of course.) Thanks for the book recommendations.

Reply
Guy
10/9/2015 16:16:42

Nice piece Max

Reply
Tony
22/9/2015 20:50:15

Are you sure you fell out of love with football? Sounds more like the end of the affair with Coventry.

Reply
Michael Blunk
25/3/2016 23:05:56

Max,

Hi. I'm a friend of Mark Butterworth. An American from Boston living near Uzes for the past 5 years. Knowing that I have a love for the Red Sox and Dylan, he gave passed along the link to your website. Just wanted to say that I've had a great pleasure perusing through it tonight. Thanks for writing and if you're ever back in town let's get in touch. All the best!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

     Max Smith

    European writer, radical, restaurateur and Red Sox fan. 70-something husband, father, step-father. and grandfather. Resident in Warwick, England.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Art
    Baseball
    Books
    Film
    Food + Drink
    French Letters
    Leamington Letters
    Media
    Music
    People
    Personal
    Politics
    Sport